When meeting people who have adopted a dog, I very often hear that they are deeply disappointed with their new four-legged housemate. They wanted a different dog, behaving differently. Everything was supposed to be beautiful, wonderful and colourful…
Many may initially want to criticise them, but that is not entirely fair. We need to analyse everything carefully to understand. It often begins with people deciding to adopt, not always on impulse but after serious thought. They visit a shelter or contact an organisation. Things go reasonably well if they find people caring for homeless dogs professionally and conscientiously, rather than merely trying to move an animal on. Sadly, my observations and conversations suggest we are still far from that ideal.
In many places, those around dogs not only lack knowledge of canine psychology but treat animals as goods or objects. Many are so dishonest that they present wonderful animal lives online while everyday reality differs greatly from what internet audiences are fed. I have witnessed staged displays myself. At the shelter where I spent so much time helping, reality was far removed from what appeared online. Selfless helpers who saw too much were unwelcome — unless they thought less and saw nothing.
One recent client knew little about canine psychology, which was her right. She grieved deeply after her dog died, and after some time decided to give a homeless animal a home. She told the person she approached about her previous dog, their relationship, life together and expectations of a future dog. Someone pretended to listen. Instead of explaining that dogs with difficult pasts are often an unknown, they said it was wonderful she had come because they had an identical dog. She believed them and was delighted. From the outset, things differed from the family’s expectations. Nobody explained anything. Worse for the new dog, everyone constantly compared him with their deceased dog. The previous dog had lived with them from puppyhood; this dog was older and had a difficult past. His age brought another shock when tests showed he was considerably older, not one year old as the shelter claimed. The same story again. Why? Misrepresenting age does nothing for these animals and deceives people horribly. Such dogs are often expected to do things they no longer have the desire or strength to do.
The adopted dog could not cope with everything or his emotions. Nobody understood him. The family began hitting him and considered giving him to friends to live in an outdoor pen. One “specialist” had advised hitting and jerking to teach him who ruled the home. Fortunately, before giving him away, his owner contacted me. Some time has passed since our first meeting. There has been considerable work and great progress. I am glad another family’s thinking about dogs has changed. They did not mean harm but did not know there was a completely different way. They felt disappointed and deceived, understandably: they had expectations, and instead of explaining reality, someone falsely reinforced those expectations and took advantage of them.
I always feel happy and admiring when someone adopts a dog. Beginning life with a dog who has a difficult past is a great gesture and challenge. I know that well. I also know how much work, knowledge and time are needed to help thoughtfully and, above all, understand their emotions. I understand that prospective adopters may not know. But people paid to care for these animals should pull themselves together, stop treating them as goods, remember their emotions and stop passing on foolish “knowledge”. Until that changes, most of these animals will continue suffering.
